Rent data · Free

Rent data for ZIP 33040, Florida Keys

In September 2026, the typical asking rent in ZIP 33040 (Key West / Old Town) was $3,506 (Zillow ZORI), down 1.9% from August and down 4.6% from a year earlier. It is the lowest typical rent among the 2 Florida Keys ZIPs in SignalPoint's December snapshot, $57 below the city of Key West figure of $3,563.

The numbers for this ZIP

FigureValue
ZORI typical rent, Sep 2026$3,506
Month over month-1.9%
Year over year-4.6%
HUD FY2026 SAFMR, 2BR (voucher payment standard)$2,800
ACS median gross rent (2020–24, five-year survey)$2,167
City of Key West ZORI, Sep 2026$3,563 (-1.4% MoM, -9.8% YoY)

The 2BR Small Area FMR for 33040 is $2,800. The full 0–4BR SAFMR table for this ZIP is in the Florida Keys Rent Snapshot: December 2026. SAFMR figures are voucher payment standards, not market rents.

What the data shows

  • Direction. 33040 was down 1.9% from August and down 4.6% from a year earlier; the city of Key West was -1.4% on the month and -9.8% on the year.
  • Position in the set. Next higher in the set: 33037 (Key Largo), $3,690.
  • HUD vs. ZORI. The 2BR SAFMR ($2,800) sits $706 below the ZIP's ZORI. SAFMR is a voucher payment standard built for a 2-bedroom; ZORI is an all-homes asking-rent index, so the two measure different things.
  • Occupied homes. The ACS median gross rent ($2,167) is a five-year survey of occupied renter homes, shown for context; it is not a current asking rent.
  • Thin coverage. Only two Florida Keys ZIPs, Key Largo (33037) and Key West (33040), carry ZORI data in Zillow's file; no other Keys ZIP can be tabled.

What this page does not show

  • A rent for a specific address. ZORI is a ZIP-wide index across rental types.
  • Bedroom-level asking rents. The public ZIP file is an all-homes blend.
  • Days on market or concessions for this ZIP.

Other ZIPs in this set

Research for one property in 33040

The full Florida Keys Rent Snapshot: December 2026 has the complete figures. A city or ZIP index is not a figure for one address. For written, human-checked market research on one 33040 property, built from hand-picked comps, order the $99 Rental Market Analysis or the $149 Competitor Snapshot. You make all pricing and leasing decisions. Questions are answered by email.

Not useful? Full refund within 2 days, no questions asked. Refund policy

Sources

  • Zillow Research, Zillow Observed Rent Index (ZORI), ZIP file. Latest month in file: 2026-09-30. Accessed November 12, 2026.
  • U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, FY2026 Small Area Fair Market Rents. Accessed November 12, 2026.
  • U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020–2024 5-year estimates, Median Gross Rent (table B25064), ZIP Code Tabulation Area 33040. Accessed November 12, 2026.

← Back to rent data by city