Monthly data · Free

Florida Keys Rent Snapshot: December 2026

Typical rents across the two Florida Keys ZIPs with published Zillow ZORI data, with month-over-month and year-over-year change, plus HUD FY2026 Small Area Fair Market Rents — sourced only from free public data.

Next snapshot: early January 2027, with November data.

This is SignalPoint Intelligence's first monthly Florida Keys Rent Snapshot: a free, citable look at typical rents across the Florida Keys, built only from public data I could fetch and verify. Figures below are not invented, not averaged from private scrapes, and not a substitute for property-specific comps. One article covers the whole chain — each key on its own is too small for a standalone snapshot.

Primary asking-rent measure: Zillow Observed Rent Index (ZORI) for September 2026 (file dated through 2026-09-30, accessed November 12, 2026 Eastern). Administrative rent standards: HUD FY2026 Small Area Fair Market Rents by ZIP. Occupied-unit context: Census ACS 2020–2024 median gross rent. Days on market are omitted because no free, ZIP-level rental DOM series was available on the access date.

Need written market research for one Florida Keys property — not a ZIP average?

Not useful? Full refund within 2 days, no questions asked. Refund policy

Key findings

  • Only two ZIPs in the whole island chain carry ZORI data in Zillow's file: Key Largo (33037, $3,690) and Key West (33040, $3,506) — a $184 spread. Zillow publishes no ZIP-level ZORI for Islamorada, Marathon, Big Pine Key, Tavernier, or any other Key, so they cannot be tabled.
  • The Key West metro ZORI was $3,671 in September 2026, down -0.8% month over month and -0.4% year over year — the highest metro typical rent in the entire snapshot series (all twelve articles), roughly 90% above the national figure. Monroe County was $3,671 (-0.8% MoM, -0.4% YoY) — identical to the metro, because the county is the metro.
  • The City of Key West ZORI was $3,563, down -1.4% month over month and -9.8% year over year — the sharpest city-level year-over-year decline in the series. Key Largo moved the other way, up +2.7% year over year. The two ends of the chain moved in opposite directions.
  • HUD FY2026 countywide Fair Market Rent for a 2-bedroom in Monroe County is $2,504. ZIP-level Small Area FMRs for 2-bedrooms are $2,450 (33037) and $2,800 (33040) — roughly $900–$1,200 below current ZORI in both cases, the widest ZORI-vs-SAFMR gap in the series.
  • Read the ACS figures with extra care here. The ACS median gross rents ($2,167 for Key West, $1,899 for Key Largo) sit far below current ZORI because they describe older occupied stock, not today's asking rents — and in a thin, seasonal, short-term-rental-heavy market, the gap between sitting tenants and new listings is at its widest.

Typical rent by Florida Keys ZIP

ZORI is a smoothed measure of typical observed asking rent across rental types in the ZIP, weighted toward the rental stock — not the rent of any one listing, and not a signed lease. Area labels are informal neighborhood shorthand for the ZIP, not official boundaries.

ZIP / area ZORI typical rent
(Sep 2026)
MoM YoY HUD FY2026
SAFMR 2BR
ACS median
gross rent
(2020–24)
33037
Key Largo
$3,690+1.6%+2.7%$2,450$1,899
33040
Key West / Old Town
$3,506-1.9%-4.6%$2,800$2,167

MoM compares September 2026 to August 2026 ZORI. YoY compares September 2026 to September 2025 ZORI. ACS median gross rent is a five-year survey of occupied renter homes and includes selected utilities; it is usually lower than current asking-rent indices and is shown for context, not as a current list price.

Metro, city and county context

Geography ZORI Sep 2026 MoM YoY
Key West metro$3,671-0.8%-0.4%
City of Key West$3,563-1.4%-9.8%
Monroe County$3,671-0.8%-0.4%

Monroe County HUD Fair Market Rents for FY2026 (countywide, not ZIP): studio $1,726, 1BR $2,211, 2BR $2,504, 3BR $3,303, 4BR $3,315.

HUD FY2026 Small Area Fair Market Rents

Small Area FMRs are HUD's ZIP-level rent standards used for Housing Choice Voucher payment standards in Monroe County, FL. They are administrative benchmarks, not asking rents.

ZIP 0 BR 1 BR 2 BR 3 BR 4 BR
33037$1,690$2,160$2,450$3,230$3,240
33040$1,930$2,470$2,800$3,690$3,710

What the data shows

  • ZIP-level figures vary more than the metro headline. Key Largo (33037, $3,690) and Key West (33040, $3,506) moved in opposite directions this year — one up +2.7%, one down -4.6%. A metro average of $3,671 describes neither.
  • ZORI is a market index, not a unit-level figure. It is a smoothed measure of typical asking rent across the rental stock. Individual units differ by beds, baths, condition, parking, laundry and pet policy, so they sit at different points inside a ZIP's range. Long-term rental stock is thin across the Keys, and a single large complex leasing up can move a ZIP's index.
  • Monthly and yearly moves can point in different directions. A ZIP can be soft year over year while ticking up month over month, or the reverse; one month is not a trend until the next release confirms it. The City of Key West is down -9.8% year over year while the metro is essentially flat (-0.4%).
  • HUD SAFMR and market rent measure different things. SAFMR is an administrative benchmark built for voucher payment standards, not a market asking rent. Both Keys 2BR SAFMRs ($2,450–$2,800) sit $706–$1,240 below current ZORI ($1,240 in Key Largo, $706 in Key West).
  • The ZIP index has limits. It does not describe any one unit. Active and recently leased comps for a specific bed count and finish level are a separate data set. ZORI is a long-term asking-rent index and does not capture short-term nightly rates or occupancy; the $99 Rental Market Analysis is written research on those comps for one property.

Need written market research for one Florida Keys property — not a ZIP average?

Not useful? Full refund within 2 days, no questions asked. Refund policy

How to read these numbers

  • ZORI (Zillow Observed Rent Index): smoothed typical observed asking rent for the geography, quality-adjusted and weighted to the rental stock. Dollar-denominated using the middle of the rent distribution. Source file: Zip_zori_uc_sfrcondomfr_sm_month.csv (and metro/city/county counterparts).
  • HUD SAFMR / FMR: fiscal-year administrative rents. FY2026 figures shown here. Not the same as what a landlord should list tomorrow.
  • ACS median gross rent: five-year survey estimate for occupied renter households; includes utilities when paid by the renter. Lagged and different population than current listings.
  • Neighborhood names next to ZIPs are approximate labels for readability. Always confirm comps against the property's actual street and building type.
  • Metro and county are the same geography here: Monroe County is the Key West MSA, so the metro and county ZORI figures are the same row.

What I could not include

  • Days on market: omitted. No free, citable ZIP-level rental days-on-market series was fetchable on November 12, 2026. (Zillow's free research CSVs for days-to-pending are sale-side, not rental.)
  • Bedroom-level asking rents by ZIP: ZORI in the public ZIP file is an all-homes blend, not a 1BR/2BR/3BR split. HUD SAFMR provides bedroom breaks for voucher standards only.
  • Apartment List / Redfin rental medians: not included in the tables because a stable, ZIP-level public CSV matching these ZIPs was not retrieved on the access date.
  • This snapshot does not price any specific address. Condition, amenities and lease terms still dominate.
  • Only two ZIPs: Zillow publishes ZIP-level ZORI for just two Keys ZIPs (33037 Key Largo, 33040 Key West). Islamorada, Marathon, Big Pine Key, Tavernier and the other Keys have no rows in the file, so they cannot be tabled.
  • Short-term rental occupancy and nightly rates: not included. No citable free source was retrieved on the access date, so the STR character of the market is described qualitatively in the landlord section.

Sources

  • Zillow Research, Zillow Observed Rent Index (ZORI), public CSV downloads — ZIP, metro, city and county files (*_zori_uc_sfrcondomfr_sm_month.csv). Latest month in file: 2026-09-30. Accessed November 12, 2026 (America/New_York) from zillow.com/research/data / files.zillowstatic.com. Zillow revises history with each release; this snapshot reflects the file as downloaded on the access date.
  • U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, FY2026 Small Area Fair Market Rents for Monroe County, FL (ZIP table) and FY2026 Fair Market Rents for Monroe County (countywide), from HUD's FY2026 FMR files (fy2026_safmrs.xlsx, fy26_fmrs.xlsx) via huduser.gov. Accessed November 12, 2026.
  • U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020–2024 5-year estimates, Median Gross Rent (table B25064), for ZIP Code Tabulation Areas matching the 2 ZIPs above, via the Census Reporter API. Accessed November 12, 2026. ACS figures are survey estimates with margins of error; they are not current asking rents.
  • Zillow Research, September 2026 Rent Report — national typical rent $1,932/mo (ZORI, September 2026), the basis for the "roughly 90% above the national figure" comparison above. Accessed November 12, 2026.